James Clapper Cites Brotherhood as Defense against Al-Qaeda

In his statement for the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, U.S. Director of National Intelligence James Clapper appears to endorse the concept Muslim Brotherhood involvement in the Mideast political process will serve as some kind of bulwark against Al-Qaeda and other such groups. He writes:
If, over the longer term, governments take real steps to address public demands for political participation and democratic institutions—and remain committed to CT efforts—we judge that core al-Qaeda and the global jihadist movement will experience a strategic setback. Al Qaeda probably will find it difficult to compete for local support with groups like the Muslim Brotherhood that participate in the political process, provide social services, and advocate religious values. Nonviolent, pro-democracy demonstrations challenge al Qaeda’s violent jihadist ideology and might yield increased political power for secular or moderate Islamist parties.
In February 2011, author and former Wall Street Journal reporter Ian Johnson published an article titled “Washington’s Secret History with the Muslim Brotherhood” in which he reviews the history of the US relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood and should serve as a cautionary note regarding the policies implied above. The piece begins:
As US-backed strongmen around North Africa and the Middle East are being toppled or shaken by popular protests, Washington is grappling with a crucial foreign-policy issue: how to deal with the powerful but opaque Muslim Brotherhood. In Egypt, the Brotherhood has taken an increasingly forceful part in the protests, issuing a statement Thursday calling for Mubarak’s immediate resignation. And though it is far from clear what role the Brotherhood would have should Mubarak step down, the Egyptian president has been claiming it will take over. In any case, the movement is likely to be a major player in any transitional government.Journalists and pundits are already weighing in with advice on the strengths and dangers of this 83-year-old Islamist movement, whose various national branches are the most potent opposition force in virtually all of these countries. Some wonder how the Brotherhood will treat Israel, or if it really has renounced violence. Most—including the Obama administration —seem to think that it is a movement the West can do business with, even if the White House denies formal contacts.If this discussion evokes a sense of déjà vu, this is because over the past sixty years we have had it many times before, with almost identical outcomes. Since the 1950s, the United States has secretly struck up alliances with the Brotherhood or its offshoots on issues as diverse as fighting communism and calming tensions among European Muslims. And if we look to history, we can see a familiar pattern: each time, US leaders have decided that the Brotherhood could be useful and tried to bend it to America’s goals, and each time, maybe not surprisingly, the only party that clearly has benefited has been the Brotherhood.
Read the rest here.
Previous posts discussed Mr. Johnson’s book on the history of the Munich mosque and his paper for the Hudson Institute titled “The Brotherhood’s Westward Expansion” which traces the connections between the Muslim Brotherhood as it developed in Europe and the United States.
Related posts:
  1. MIDEAST CRISIS: Office Of US Director Of National Intelligence Corrects Director’s Claim That Muslim Brotherhood Is Secular
  2. MIDEAST CRISIS: US National Intelligence Director Says Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood “Largely Secular”
  3. MPAC Cites Another DHS Conference Call
  4. CAIR Cites Involvement With U.S. Government As Defense
  5. White House National Security Official Gives Speech At DC Center Tied To US Muslim Brotherhood
Dr. Mohammad Badie
The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood website is reporting that the head of the Brotherhood met Tuesday with a French delegation that included the French ambassador and lectured them on “Islamophobia.” According to the report:
Dr. Mohammad Badie, Chairman of the Muslim Brotherhood (MB), received in his office Tuesday afternoon, Hervé Gaymard, France’s former Finance Minister and president of the French National Assembly’s Egyptian-French Friendship Group, Jean Felix-Paganon, the French ambassador in Cairo, and their accompanying delegation (members of the French National Assembly), as well as Ms. Laura Bazan, a Committee on Foreign Relations adviser. Dr. Badie emphasized that the Brotherhood is an all-inclusive Islamic institution, and that it established the Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) to be its political arm. He added that the FJP has formed an alliance of all the spectra of Egyptian political and social hues. He also mentioned that coordination with the FJP is confined to major, crucial decisions and basic positions and views, like presidential and Cabinet elections, and that the party is fully independent in all other affairs, subject to the vision of its elected institutions. The MB Chairman asserted that U.S. and Western governments’ clear bias and their dealing with double standards with regard to Palestinian issues damage and impede good relations with the Arab and Muslim peoples, pointing out that relations between peoples are the most durable, powerful and resilient. Dr. Badie expressed his hope the falsehood of Islamophobia – the lie of the Islamist Scarecrow would vanish forever, “Let’s judge what is happening on the grounds of hard facts, not fabricated lies”.
In December of 2011, a post reported that U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee head John Kerry and the U.S. Ambassador to Egypt visited the headquarters of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood.
Numerous GMBDR posts have observed that so-called Islamophobia is a major theme of the Global Muslim Brotherhood. For one example of how the Brotherhood uses the concept, go here.
Related posts:
  1. Hamas Delegation Meets With Leader Of The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood
  2. Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood Leader Meets With Sudanese Opposition Leaders In Cairo
  3. French Muslim Brotherhood Leader Says Government Must Pass Law Against Islamaphobia
  4. Russian Ambassador Meets With Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood
  5. French Muslim Brotherhood Leader Elected Vice-President Of French Islamic Council
Reproduced with permission from the Global Muslim Brotherhood Daily Report.

blog comments powered by Disqus

FSM Archives

10 year FSM Anniversary